Plus the Eric immunity fiasco. Also "It's a f**king stick!", and Eliza & her face just in general. Catalie Bolton coming outta nowhere after the merge. That was a pretty decent Season in retrospect. Krazy Kathy had an emotional breakdown and it actually made her rootable, unlike say, Lisa or Dawn more recently.
Do correct me if I'm adding in parts from other years to my dim recollection.
I'm a big fan of Tyson's in Tocantins too, even though he's one of my favorite players ever. Him shitting on Sierra the whole tribal, saying he loves everyone but her and then winking at Brendan is one of my favorite moments ever.
Tyson's blindside in Tocantins has gotta be in my top 5. But I think the best ever is the original: Gretchen's in Borneo. Anyone who didn't vote for her that night would have never dreamed of voting her out in a billion years. Also: 4-1-1-1-1-1-1. <3 Amazing all around. It made the game what it is today.
I also love Jason's in Micronesia. I think that one is overlooked a lot.
I only liked Lisa after the breakdown. The recovery was good and I loved her and Skupin playing together as a duo so well. Someone at a forum I post on mentioned at the time it was like "watching your grandparents play together", which I think nailed it on the head. She was so torn, and he was so err, willing to do what ever it took to protect her. It is rare to see anyone in that game who isn't just completely self-serving when it comes down to it actually go far <3
But yeah, not a fan mid-breakdown, only afterwards.